Friday, April 19, 2019

Performer

I had two patients related to each other: a 10-year-old boy and his grandfather.

I had finished with the boy and was already examining his grandfather when I heard the boy sing in falsetto (the boy was also dancing).

I told the boy there’s money in singing, not in dancing.

The boy suddenly performed a body wave dance and said, “Mas gusto ko sayaw.  Gusto ko maging call boy.  (I like dancing better.  I want to be a call boy).”

His grandparents (the grandmother was also there) and I laughed. 

Where did a 10-year-old boy get that idea?  In Fuckbook perhaps.  Oh well.

The boy is handsome (I rarely see handsome patients in that clinic) and very friendly.  Whether he wants to be a call boy or something else in the future, I think he will succeed.

Sunday, April 14, 2019

Acting and Prostitution in History

Actors and prostitutes1 had a lot in common hundreds and thousands of years ago.

In ancient Rome, actors, prostitutes, and gladiators belonged to the “infamous professions.”

“Actors, gladiators, and prostitutes in ancient Rome were symbols of the shameful.  Their signal lack of reputation was reflected and reinforced in the law” (Edwards 66).

Infames (plural of infamis) were people of disrepute.  People who became infames legally could not appear in the court of law to give testimony or to complain, could not hold public office, and could be beaten like slaves.

Infamia (infamy) was the loss of legal or social standing.  People convicted of crimes might become infamous as punishment (so they lost their legal standing), but actors, prostitutes, and gladiators were already considered infamous by their very professions (so they did not have social and legal standing to begin with).

The verb prostitute means to sell one’s body or to exchange money for sex.  The infamous non-prostitutes did not necessarily sell their body for sex.  Their stigma came from the fact that they served to pleasure others by putting on a performance for the public to consume.

Not all public performers were so disparaged.  The aurigae (plural of auriga, charioteer or driver in modern language) were not always slaves or hired professionals but the elite themselves. Also, the focus was on the horses, mitigating the stigma of the body performing for the public.

If we apply infamia to the present day, drivers are above actors and other performers.  In particular, race car drivers find prestige in race tracks like the 24 Hours of Le Mans.2  I have yet to see a cab driver tell a movie star, “You’re just an entertainer.  I’m a driver.”

Some people in ancient Rome lost their elite status by avoiding punishment for adultery through registering as a prostitute.  Prostitution was legal, and prostitutes were allowed multiple sexual partners.

The lowly status of actors, prostitutes, and gladiators did not prevent the Roman elite to associate with them.  Actors and gladiators were celebrities, lowly but celebrities nevertheless.

Emperor Commodus3 played as a gladiator in the games to the dismay of the senators (for insulting the throne by becoming an infamis) and to the delight of the commoners.

Sulla, the predecessor of Julius Caesar, had Metrobius (an actor) for a lover.  Sulla had wives and children, and bisexuality4 was common in ancient Rome.

Politicians went on smear campaigns alleging their opponents were infamous (common tactic even to this day).  The acclaimed orator Cicero alleged that Mark Antony, famous for being the lover of Cleopatra and protégé of Julius Caesar, became a prostitute in a woman’s outfit when he (Mark Antony) had become bankrupt (The Second Philippic 2.44-47).

The early modern period saw the rise of the kabuki theater in Japan in the 1600s.  Kabuki rose to fame quickly but at some point was stigmatized because in its early days “many of the actresses in this popular theater genre were also prostitutes” (Frederic 441 [Roth]).

Chinese actors in theaters and cinema likewise were associated with prostitutes.

China is an older civilization than ancient Rome, and “for most of Chinese history, the roles of performers and prostitutes were closely associated, and the two were lumped together in a single legal category (and in popular morality) right up to the Qing Dynasty (1644-1911)” (Wu 220).

“The lack of respect given movie stars was a major obstacle to the development of Chinese cinema.  It deterred many talented people from entering a world looked upon as corrupt” (Xiao 9).

The actors’ fame and money have uplifted them.  Hollywood, I expect, has something to do with this.

We love them actors, don’t we?  Regardless of their origins.

It takes time for people to change their views about, and ways of dealing with, those who are different.  Writing for comic books was not considered prestigious decades ago.  Except for a select few, writers were not credited in the golden age (from the appearance of Superman in 1938 to the mid-1950s) of comics.  These days, comic book writers are pursued by companies like DC and Marvel, and their names always appear in comic book issues.

Prostitution is not always about exploitation, and prostitutes are not necessarily villainous like thieves, so why the continued prejudice against them?

Will prostitution, allegedly the oldest profession in the world, be able to cast off infamia?  I hope for that to happen one day.


NOTES

1The politically correct term for prostitute is sex worker.

2The 24 Hours of Le Mans is an endurance race where drivers race for 24 hours.  Each car is assigned more than one driver.  The drivers alternate in driving their assigned car for the duration of the race.

3I talked about Commodus in my blog post “The Roman Empire and the United States: Immigrants Make a Nation Great.”

4Sexuality as we understand it today is not the same in ancient Rome.  Roman men had no issue with same-sex encounters provided certain rules were followed: (1) Roman citizens could not have same-sex encounters with fellow Roman citizens.  Prostitutes, slaves, and foreigners did not have the privileges of a Roman citizen, so a Roman could have them.  (2) A Roman man must be the insertor, the penetrator, in the sex act.  If a Roman man allowed anal penetration, he is a pathicus or a cinaedus, and would lose his social, not legal, standing and become an infamis (people looked down on a pathicus, but a pathicus from the upper class remained an elite legally – Emperor Commodus became an infamis socially when he fought as a gladiator but he did not become an infamis legally because he remained the emperor of Rome).  These two rules of same-sex engagement, I expect, were regularly broken secretly.  Why the brouhaha over backdoor entry?  Because for Roman men, being penetrated meant playing the part of a woman, and the ancient Romans were anti-woman nincompoops.


POSTSCRIPTS

For me, the most remarkable product of Le Mans is Carroll Shelby, the man responsible for those odd-looking, but beautiful Cobra cars.

A poster of the Le Mans race appears in the gay film Call Me By Your Name starring Armie Hammer and Timothee Chalamet.

The City of Manila in the Philippines had a movie house along Avenida called Odeon.  The Odeon endures but is now a bazaar and is no longer a movie house.  The term odeon is Greek and is called odeum in Latin.  Odeon is a small, roofed theater, also referred to as theatrum tectum or covered theater (Oxford 1032).


REFERENCES

“Odeum.”  The Oxford Classical Dictionary.  4th ed.  Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2012.  1032.

The 24 Hour War.  Dir. Nate Adams and Adam Carolla.  24 Hour War, 2016.  Film.

Baytan, Robert.  “The Roman Empire and the United States: Immigrants Make a Nation Great.”  3 Jan. 2019.  Web.  <https://robertbaytan.blogspot.com/2019/01/the-roman-empire-and-united-states.html>.

Call Me By Your Name.  Screenplay by James Ivory.  Dir. Luca Guadagnino.  Perf.  Armie Hammer, Timothee Chalamet.  Frenesy, La Cinefacture, 2017.  Film.

Cicero, The Second Philippic 2.44-47.  [Available in Latin and English texts in different formats including The Complete Works of Cicero.  Delphi Classics, 2014.  ePub.]

The Cobra Ferrari Wars.  Dir. Richard Symons.  Narr. Robbie Coltrane.  BBC, 2002.  Film.  [The narrator, Robbie Coltrane, plays Rubeus Hagrid in the Harry Potter film series.]

Edwards, Catharine.  “Unspeakable Professions: Public Performance and Prostitution in Ancient Rome.”  Roman Sexualities.  Eds. Judith P. Hallett and Marilyn B. Skinner.  Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1997.  66-95.

Frederic, Louis.  “Kabuki.”  Japan Encyclopedia.  Trans. Kathe Roth.  Cambridge, MA: The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 2002.  441-442.

Wu, Cuncun.  “Imperial Chinese Theater.”  Encyclopedia of Prostitution and Sex Work.  Ed. Melissa Hope Ditmore.  Vol. 1.  Westport, CT: Greenwood Press, 2006.  220-222.

Xiao, Zhuwei.  “Chinese Cinema: Early Film People.”  Encyclopedia of Chinese Film.  Ed. Yingjin Zhang.  London: Routledge, 1998.  8-10.

Saturday, April 6, 2019

Normal Heart, Abnormal Anti-LGBT Lawmakers


There are movie scenes that get burned into our memory strongly for reasons peculiar to our personal constitution and deep-seated affiliations.  The following scenes describe some of the most remarkable movie scenes in my mind.

The Normal Heart is a film about the early days of AIDS (acquired immune deficiency syndrome) when the disease was erroneously attributed to gays.  In one of the scenes, Albert (Finn Wittrock) was brought to the hospital but died by the time he got in.  No doctor or any medical staff wanted to touch him.  His body, placed in oversized black garbage bags, was thrown in the trash alley.  Bruce (Taylor Kitsch), Albert’s lover, had to pay the orderly 50 dollars just to get the body.  Albert’s mother (Catherine Chadwick) looked on, crying, and cried some more when Bruce held her.  They then went to the funeral parlor to have Albert’s body cremated.

A human being thrown in the trash, within hospital premises.  What the fuck!

I can only imagine how Albert’s mother felt, seeing her child literally treated as trash.  I can imagine how Bruce felt losing his lover in a hospital that declined medical care.  Well, the hospital personnel provided non-medical care brimming with inhuman touch.

I am acutely reminded of The Normal Heart because of what happened to the United States very recently.

Earlier this month (this week), Texas passed Senate Bill 17 which would allow professionals (doctors, lawyers, judges, accountants, pharmacists, et al.), based on their deeply held religious beliefs, to refuse to give services to LGBTs (lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender).

This is setting a dangerous precedent for future discriminatory laws against my American siblings (the LGBTs).

It is wrong to use religion to impact the law.  To these lawmakers, it is more important to hate and discriminate than to serve humanity.

Albert in the trash alley may happen again.  Well, Albert was trashed during the AIDS crisis in the 1980s at a time, supposedly, when professionals – especially medical professionals – could not discriminate in providing needed services.  What more with laws protecting the professionals’ deeply held religious beliefs?  Albert on a mountain of humans, trashed.  Maybe.  Goodness, I hope not.

When will people learn?

REFERENCES

Christine Bolaños.  “Texas ‘Religious Freedom’ Bill Opens Door to LGBT Discrimination, Opponents Say.”  The Guardian.  6 Apr. 2019.  Web.  6 Apr. 2019.  <https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2019/apr/05/texas-sb17-lgbt-discrimination-religious-freedom>.
[There are other news outlets that carried this story.  You can Google them (or use the search engine of your choice)].

The Normal Heart.  Screenplay by Larry Kramer.  Dir. Ryan Murphy.  Perf. Mark Ruffalo, Julia Roberts, Taylor Kitsch, Finn Wittrock, Catherine Chadwick.  Home Box Office, 2014.  Film.